As president, Grant broke the KKK and fought for Black voting rights with a tenacity few other presidents have rivaled. Are you sure you want to delete this comment? But another, perhaps more useful lesson is that we need to think about heroism differently. Start your Independent Premium subscription today. Shaw and 40 percent of his regiment were killed in 1863 in an attack on Fort Wagner in South Carolina. Alone, Shaw is nothing. But another, perhaps more useful lesson is that we need to think about heroism differently. The story: According to the San Francisco police around 400 people gathered in Golden Gate Park to take down the statue on Friday, which Juneteenth, a day that commemorates the […] That's why the best memorials are those which embed people in their time and community, rather than trying to lift them above it. The statue of Grant, who also served as the nation’s eighteenth president, was among three monuments in San Francisco’s Golden Gate Park knocked down during the evening by a group of protesters. Quiz: Can you match the nickname to the National Football League player? Create a commenting name to join the debate, There are no Independent Premium comments yet - be the first to add your thoughts, There are no comments yet - be the first to add your thoughts. But Grant's legacy also has less admirable aspects. here for reprint permission, Trump presses Georgia’s secretary of state in phone call about alleged election fraud, Republicans warn of ‘generational damage’ from left if Georgia Democrats win Senate races. In San Francisco's Golden Gate Park, ... protesters also pulled down a statue of Ulysses S Grant — the Union general responsible for the defeat of the Confederacy — because he owned a slave. But the Shaw family were dissatisfied with that idea. The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium. Ulysses S. Grant statue toppled in San Francisco. Trump cancels Camp David trip, hunkers down at White House They, “Together," the monument reads, “they gave to the nation and the world undying proof that Americans of African descent possess the pride, courage and devotion of the patriotic soldier. Please continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates. Grant served two terms in the White House after helping to win the Civil War. - JavaScript is required for full functionality on this website, but scripting is currently disabled. Shaw was the white captain of the 54. With the men of the 54th, though, he points to a better world, in which memorials are more honest and more brave, and Black lives matter. The designer of the Shaw memorial, Augustus Saint-Gaudens, originally planned a typical noble-guy-on-horse, standalone statue. Saturday, June 20, 2020, Hunter Biden email associate on Justice Department transition team. Their story suggests that we too might give meaning to our lives by doing the unthinkable and daring the impossible on behalf of justice.". Rather, it is a tribute to his solidarity with the Black men he fought with, and their solidarity with him. Indeed, the statues in San Francisco came down the same evening that protesters on the other side of the country successfully toppled a Confederate monument in Washington, D.C. The Pike statue has long been relatively obscure, however, in part because it depicted him in civilian dress and was designed primarily to honor his achievements in leading an order of Freemasons. Grant's record of great good and great evil isn't unique. Saint-Gaudens' final design shows Shaw on his horse against a relief of Black soldiers, which Saint-Gaudens designed from live studies of African American men from Boston and New York. With the men of the 54, , though, he points to a better world, in which memorials are more honest and more brave, and, It wasn't a mistake to pull down the statue of Ulysses S Grant, Trump attacks racial justice protests at rambling Tulsa rally, Eric Trump refers to racial justice protesters as 'animals' at rally, One person shot dead inside autonomous protest zone, reports say, Protesters topple Confederate monuments across the US on Juneteenth, You may not agree with our views, or other users’, but please respond to them respectfully, Swearing, personal abuse, racism, sexism, homophobia and other discriminatory or inciteful language is not acceptable, Do not impersonate other users or reveal private information about third parties, We reserve the right to delete inappropriate posts and ban offending users without notification. CNA Staff, Jun 20, 2020 / 09:41 am (CNA).- A statue of Catholic missionary St. Junipero Serra was toppled in a San Francisco park Friday, along with statues of Francis Scott Key and Ulysses S. Grant. Other monuments toppled on Friday include a statue of Junípero Serra, an 18th century missionary recently declared a saint in the Catholic Church, and Francis Scott Key, the author of “The Star-Spangled Banner,” the national anthem. WATCH: Statue of Ulysses Grant, Head of Union Army, Toppled. Also torn down in the San Francisco park was a statue of Francis Scott Key, who wrote the U.S. national anthem “Star Spangled Banner.” Key … Grant also supported the 1868 Republican platform when he won the presidency, which called for allowing Black men to continue voting in the South. But even people who are admirable in some ways often are less so in others. A bronze bust of Ulysses S. Grant was installed in San Francisco's Golden Gate Park, in the U.S. state of California, in 1896. The rioters justified taking down Key's statue because he was a … The monument doesn't honor Shaw alone or individually. Anti-racism protesters ripped down statues of Ulysses S. Grant and Francis Scott Key in San Francisco while SWAT team officers arrested an armed man seen suspiciously recording people with his cell phone while on the roof of a building overlooking a statue of Robert E. Lee in Virginia. Statue of Ulysses S. Grant as it stood in Golden Gate Park, San Francisco (Wikimedia Commons) I’m suspicious of all monuments, and I believe in dismantling those that tell warped tales about our national past, suppress its horrors, and gild its errors by encasing them in tragic dignity. But he also owned enslaved people and called for genocide against Native Americans. Masks will become a new norm after coronavirus pandemic ends, public officials predict, After making history, Citizen Trump will regain power to block Twitter followers, Double duty: Best 10mm handguns for hunting and home defense, Cuomo skewered for opening Bills game with restaurants shuttered, Doctor: “Doing This Every Morning Can Snap Back Sagging Skin (No Creams Needed)”, Uncle Sam is struggling to fill the military as 70% of U.S. youths disqualified from serving, Trump’s efforts to end ‘forever wars’ only reshuffles deployed troops. Read our full mailing list consent terms here. Please enable JavaScript and reload this page. Statues commemorating former President Ulysses S. Grant and U.S. national anthem author Francis Scott Key were toppled by protesters in San Francisco on Friday night. Demonstrators Topple Statues in San Francisco's Golden Gate Park The statues of St. Junípero Serra, Ulysses S. Grant and Francis Scott Key were torn … A similar scene took place in Downtown Raleigh, North Carolina. The fate of the statue is unknown and this post will be updated when more is learned. But his early writings are racist, and in his late Seventies he slept with his teenaged grand-niece. ", One takeaway from the protest is that we need different heroes. The cultural revolution claimed yet more defenseless statues Friday night. Notification San Francisco Mayor London Breed: “There is very real pain in this country rooted in our history of slavery and oppression, especially against African-Americans and Indigenous people. To do that, you have to fudge their flaws and their humanity. Protesters toppled a statue in San Francisco of former President Ulysses S. Grant, who famously led the Union Army to victories that crippled and ultimately brought down the Confederacy. This statue was vandalized by protestors. Ulysses S. Grant statue toppled in San Francisco By Vandana Rambaran | Fox News June 20, 2020: A statue of former President Ulysses S. Grant– the Union general who led his army to victory against the Confederacy during the Civil War– was toppled on Friday as hundreds gathered in San Francisco to celebrate Juneteenth. He instigated an illegal and bloody war against the Lakota people of the Black Hills, and used federal force to push Native people onto reservations and to slaughter the buffalo they relied on for food. Vandals also brought down a statue of Francis Scott Key, the composer of "The Star-Spangled Banner." Protests against systemic racism and police brutality have taken place worldwide in the weeks since, including in several U.S. cities where controversial monuments have recently been toppled amid that unrest. Real heroism is something we make together. Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when they can to create a true meeting of independent Premium. As president, Grant's policy towards Native American people could easily be described as cultural genocide. Their story suggests that we too might give meaning to our lives by doing the unthinkable and daring the impossible on behalf of justice. An iconic model is the memorial to Robert Shaw in Boston. Franklin Roosevelt created America's social safety net and led the country to victory over the Nazis. No arrests were made, the local CBS station added. here for reprint permission. The latest statues to be toppled by BLM protesters are that of Ulysses S. Grant, who led Northern Union soldiers in the Civil War, and Francis Scott Key, the lyricist behind ‘The Star Spangled Banner,’ puzzling and outraging many. Flawed human beings are just flawed human beings; you can't raise them up without lying about them. In San Francisco's Golden Gate Park, protestors, But Grant's legacy also has less admirable aspects. Flawed human beings are just flawed human beings; you can't raise them up without lying about them. He freed the man in 1859. Whenever you put someone on a pedestal, you physically elevate them over their fellow humans. The Shaw memorial calls those who look at it not to admire one antiracist man, but to join an antiracist community. But he also interned Japanese Americans in concentration camps. Over the weekend, Black Lives Matters protestors continued to deface and tear down memorials to those associated with slavery and racism. In San Francisco, about 400 protesters pulled down three statues: U.S. Grant, Francis Scott Key, and St. Junipero Serra. Gandhi's nonviolent protest helped to free India from colonial rule and inspired resistance movements worldwide. Grant's wife had legal ownership of several Black people when he married her, and he himself kept a person in slavery for a year before freeing him at the start of the Civil War. President Trump responded to the Pike statue’s dismantling on Twitter late Friday by calling for the immediate arrest of those involved. A statue of Abraham Lincoln at San Francisco City Hall was defaced over the weekend, the former president’s face and name covered in shiny red paint. Click But he, An iconic model is the memorial to Robert Shaw in Boston. He was a slave owner too, before the Civil War. 'I want him out': Sen. Lisa Murkowski calls on Trump to resign, casts doubt on her GOP future The Ulysses S. Grant statue was one of three monuments that rioters tore down on Friday night at San Francisco's Golden Gate Park. As historian James Loewen wrote in his beautiful essay about the memorial, "the 54th Massachusetts is…a story of human possibility. Quiz: Can you guess the REAL names of these actors? Massachusetts Infantry, the second African American regiment in the Civil War. A statue of Ulysses S. Grant, the nation's 18th president and a general who fought for the Union during the Civil War, was defaced and toppled by protesters in San Francisco on Friday Click to Read More The most insightful comments on all subjects will be published daily in dedicated articles. Copyright © 2021 The Washington Times, LLC. In San Francisco's Golden Gate Park, protestors toppled a statue of Francis Scott Key, the composer of the National Anthem and a slave owner, as well as a statue of Spanish missionary Junipero Serra, a Roman Catholic priest who forcibly converted and brutalized Native American people. Two confederate monuments torn down, one of them was dragged through the street and left on the courthouse steps. Want an ad-free experience?Subscribe to Independent Premium. You can also choose to be emailed when someone replies to your comment. Most controversially, protesters also pulled down a statue of Ulysses S Grant — the Union general responsible for the defeat of the Confederacy — because he owned a slave. By Vandana Rambaran | Fox News June 20, 2020: A statue of former President Ulysses S. Grant– the Union general who led his army to victory against the Confederacy during the Civil War– was toppled on Friday as hundreds gathered in San Francisco to celebrate Juneteenth. Protesters in San Francisco, California this week toppled the statue of former President Ulysses S. Grant, who helped win the Civil War that ended slavery. Ulysses S. Grant Protesters in San Francisco defaced and toppled the statue of former President Grant, who led the Union Army during the Civil War, in Golden State Park, on Friday, June 19. Floyd, a black man, died May 25 in the custody of the Minneapolis Police Department in Minnesota. “Together," the monument reads, “they gave to the nation and the world undying proof that Americans of African descent possess the pride, courage and devotion of the patriotic soldier." As Adam Serwer of the Atlantic points out, Grant was in many ways a fierce and committed antiracist. Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines. You can find our Community Guidelines in full here. ", Massachusetts is…a story of human possibility. Police said roughly 400 protesters were at the park around the time the statues were taken down, the local NBC affiliate reported. The statues in San Francisco are among the latest to be dismantled as monuments around the country are toppled following last month’s racially charged killing of George Floyd. One takeaway from the protest is that we need different heroes. He notably insisted that the Confederacy treat imprisoned black soldiers the same as white ones, to Robert E Lee's consternation. He owned at least one slave prior to the war, according to The American Civil War Museum. Confederate statues are an easy call; there's no reason to honor people who are notable first and foremost for defending slavery. Alone, Shaw is nothing. The Washington Times Shaw was the white captain of the 54th Massachusetts Infantry, the second African American regiment in the Civil War. Nearby statue of Ulysses S. Grant is also toppled. Confederate statues were pulled down over the weekend, including this one of Confederate general Albert Pike, Over the weekend, Black Lives Matters protestors continued to deface and tear down memorials to those associated with slavery and racism. https://thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/503685-protesters-tear-down- SAN FRANCISCO – Protesters in Golden Gate Park toppled statues of Fr. Shaw and 40 percent of his regiment were killed in 1863 in an attack on Fort Wagner in South Carolina. But the Shaw family were dissatisfied with that idea. George Washington established American independence and Democratic institutions. It allows our most engaged readers to debate the big issues, share their own experiences, discuss real-world solutions, and more. Are you sure you want to mark this comment as inappropriate? Grant, a former U.S. president, led Union forces to victory in the Civil War but owned a slave before the conflict, The San Francisco Chronicle reported. and View Comments, Terms of Use / Privacy Policy / Manage Newsletters. Or are we erasing those they harmed? TOP STORIES The incident reflects a growing debate over the legacy of the Civil War president in San Francisco, including a proposal to rename Lincoln High. Any supporter of Trump must denounce what happened at the U.S. Capitol. Five tech stories that changed life in 2020, Satirical Babylon Bee: ‘Paper of record’ for conservatives, 'I want him out': Sen. Lisa Murkowski calls on Trump to resign, casts doubt on her GOP future, Trump cancels Camp David trip, hunkers down at White House, Click Independent Premium Comments can be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium. {{#verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}} {{^verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}}, The designer of the Shaw memorial, Augustus Saint-Gaudens, originally planned a typical noble-guy-on-horse, standalone statue. Due to the sheer scale of this comment community, we are not able to give each post the same level of attention, but we have preserved this area in the interests of open debate. They're also trying to make us think about what it would mean to create an antiracist public sphere, in which prejudice and hatred are remembered, but not celebrated. Real heroism is something we make together. Quiz: US Citizenship Test - Could You Pass? Grant's wife had legal ownership of several Black people when he married her, and he himself, George Washington established American independence and Democratic institutions. As a general, he fought the Confederacy with energy and brutal commitment. If we put up a statue to Washington, or Roosevelt, or Gandhi, are we honoring their good deeds? - "American Indians experienced some of the worst massacres and grossest injustices in history while Ulysses S Grant was in office," Alysa Landry writes at Indian Country Today. They insisted that the memorial had to honor the regiment Shaw fought and died with. The statue in D.C. of Albert Pike, a brigadier general in the Confederate Army, was the only outdoor statue in the nation’s capital to honor a Confederate soldier prior to it being felled last night. U.S. elections are not worth sacrificing one’s ‘personal’ life, Healing in a national crisis, thy name is Greg Stanton, Any supporter of Trump must denounce what happened at the U.S. Capitol. Janet Yellen made more than $7 million in speaking fees in 2019, 2020, ‘Great victory’: Gun rights activists celebrate as Trump administration pulls stabilizing-brace ban, Greatest undrafted players in NFL history, Baby bust: Pandemic to spark biggest fertility declines since 1970s, Adam Carolla urges anti-lockdown Cali Dems to wake up: ‘Imagine trying to pull this s— off in 1955’. The protestors knocking down statues today are trying to get the American public to confront our legacy of racism. ... Ulysses S. Grant and Francis Scott Key being torn down in San Francisco’s Golden Gate Park. We need to change our perspective on how to memorialize complicated individuals from history, Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile. Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Protesters brought down a statue of former President Ulysses S. Grant, who also led the Union Army during the Civil War, in San Francisco’s Golden Gate Park on Friday. That’s three for three this night. Protesters on Friday toppled a statue in San Francisco of former President Ulysses S. Grant, who famously led the Union Army to victories that crippled and ultimately brought down the Confederacy.